Finish reading and commenting on final paper from 2012 course East Asian Philosophy taught for UMA. The student went through years of medical hiatus. Long time start to finish. I suspect this will be my final act as faculty member for the university.
I come across this article. It has relevance to the paper submitted.
In the introduction reference is made to Professor George McLean O.M.I. (1929-2016) and his work with kenotic theology. He was a professor of mine in Metaphysics at The Catholic University of America in 1968. Every class, if I recall correctly, he’d begin by writing on the chalkboard “Being is; Non-Being is not.” (Parmenides of Elea, c. 5th century BCE, Greek philosopher). It began an addictive investigation that has perdured these nearly sixty years.
2.2 (1) ‘Detachment’ and ‘Oneness’
The meaning of ‘detachment’ (Abgeschiedenheit), besides its
close relation with ‘letting go’ (Gelassenheit), 26 has the negative meaning of being ‘self-empty of creatures’, the opposite of ‘attachment’ and the positive sense of being ‘full of God’, which equals perfect freedom and spontaneity. 27
According to Eckhart, ‘detachment’ is the very nature of God, and
the condition of the God-man relationship, i.e. the common ground
which allows God and man to meet one another, or to go into the depths
of each other. A similar idea is found in Chiara’s mutual forsakenness.
There are four objects from which one must be detached: from
something, from everything, from oneself, and from God. 28
We may say that the first three belong to one level and the fourth to another. What follows is an elucidation of the two levels from the perspective of the effect of detachment:
The first level of detachment allows for ‘God going into man’.
This level is related to the first three objects of detachment, which are all
objects belonging to the created world. When one practices this kind of
‘detachment’, God goes into the depth of His creation. Hence, besides a
transcendent God, one has also the experience of the immanent God.
This experience of inwardness sounds like what Augustine described
when he said: “you were more inward than the most inward place of my
heart”. 29 God is closer to person’s soul than the person is to her own depths.
The second level of detachment allows for ‘man going into God’.
This is something characteristic of Eckhart. Hence the idea: man is
closer than God to His depth. 30 This idea has to do with the fourth
object of ‘detachment’, where one exercises a kind of detachment which
includes detachment from God. In other words, if ‘detachment’ is the
___________________________________
26 Caputo, The Mystical Elements in Heidegger’s Thought, 119: “Thus
Gelassenheit and Abgeschiedenheit seem to be identical ideas in Eckhart’s
mystical theology for ‘detachment’ too has this same two-fold structure:
negatively, it means to be empty of creatures, and positively, to be full of God.”
27 Wu, The Golden Age of Zen, 50: “All sufferings spring from attachment,
true joy arises from detachment.”
28 R. Schuermann, “Heidegger and Meister Eckhart on Releasement,”
Research in Phenomenology 3 (1993), 95-119 at 101-113.
29 Augustine, The Confessions Book III, ch. 6, 48-49. 30 Winkler, Meister Eckhart: Zur Einfuerung , 82.
_____________________________________
20 Chan Tak-Kwong
way to God, one has to be detached even from this way itself, including
from the feeling of God. In his German Sermon No. 48, Eckhart says:
It (intellect, spark) wants to penetrate to the simple ground,
to the still desert into which distinction never peeped,
neither Father, Son nor Holy Spirit. 31
This kind of ‘detachment’ enables man to enter into the depths of
God, sometimes called the Godhead, the ‘God beyond God’, or even a
‘not - God’ (ein nichtgot).
The noblest activity of human nature is, according to Eckhart, through ‘detachment’ from the ‘nothingness of creation’— which marks the defect of creatures—to attain the ‘nothingness of God’, which is no-thing by eminence, or ‘Oneness’, i.e. the divine source that is free of
everything so that it can become in everything. What is particular to his theory of ‘Oneness’ is that, by the grace of God, man can attain the realm of life before time or creation, a kind of eternal or essential existence, where there is not yet any distinction between life and death whatsoever. This is the realm of life like God, free from causal relations, where one is the cause of oneself. What one wants is what one is, and what one is is what one wants.
--pp. 19-20, Chinese Spirituality & Christian Communities A Kenotic Perspective , Chinese Philosophical Studies, XXXI -- Christian Philosophical Studies, XVII. (Ed. by Vincent Shen), Chapter II. Kenotic Theology: A Perspective from “Regress” Theory traced in the Thought of Chiara Lubich and Meister Eckhart,
by Chan Tak-Kwong
To study, it seems,
is to lose oneself
in that-which-is,
studied.