I'm not interested in the idea of God.
Either God is or God is not. No amount of explanation or defense, rhetoric or apologetic satisfies. If God is; fine. If God is not; also fine.
Determining the shape of human society -- who's worthy and who's not, or what form of government is best reflective of the will of God -- has been an iffy, if not miserable, effort.
Another thing -- whether using God talk or in political analysis, puppet-metaphors and explanations based on puppetry, strings, or manipulation -- these modes fail to satisfy. I cannot comprehend the religious tension promulgated through history based on the question whether proper human action is dictated by God, or, human action is best determined by acuity of reason.
It seems God, church, believers, or state -- in their attempt to determine and control how human behavior should be in the face of the notion of God's revelation as to how human behavior should be -- have caused mischief and suffering, war and hatred in their haste to posit the source of salvation outside the person, place, or thing we know as the 'individual', or, the undivided.
The English philosopher Thomas Hobbes tried to find a way out of this labyrinth. Traditionally, political theology had interpreted a set of revealed divine commands and applied them to social life. In his great treatise “Leviathan” (1651), Hobbes simply ignored the substance of those commands and talked instead about how and why human beings believed God revealed them. He did the most revolutionary thing a thinker can ever do — he changed the subject, from God and his commands to man and his beliefs. If we do that, Hobbes reasoned, we can begin to understand why religious convictions so often lead to political conflicts and then perhaps find a way to contain the potential for violence.
...
Rousseau spoke of religion in terms of human needs, not divine truths, and had his Savoyard vicar declare, “I believe all particular religions are good when one serves God usefully in them.” For that, he was hounded by pious Christians.
...
...Hobbes’s iron law: Messianic theology eventually breeds messianic politics. The idea of redemption is among the most powerful forces shaping human existence in all those societies touched by the biblical tradition.
(--from The Politics of God, New York Times Magazine, Published: August 19, 2007. Mark Lilla is professor of the humanities at Columbia University. This essay is adapted from his book “The Stillborn God: Religion, Politics and the Modern West.”)
Here's what I hold as true:
- silence is lovely.
- breakfast is gift.
- water is life.
- companionship is best when free of cant. (main entry 6, noun, in Merriam-Webster online)
- walks and naps are de rigueur.
We need to spare one another from religious or spiritual encumbrance. Also political claptrap invoking deity and specialized moral imperative.
I opt for clear thinking and inclusive consideration of each being's well being.
Devote yourself to Absolute Emptiness;
Contemplate earnestly in Quiescence.
All things are together in Action,
But I look into their Non-action,
For things are continuously moving, restless,
Yet each is proceeding back to its origin.
Proceeding back to the origin means Quiescence.
To be in Quiescence is to see Being-for-itself.
- Lao tzu
If I shut up now...
Will you?
If I open up now...
Will we?
William Carlos Williams summarized his poetic method in the phrase "No ideas but in things" (from his 1944 poem "A Sort of a Song").
A Sort of a Song
Let the snake wait under
his weed
and the writing
be of words, slow and quick, sharp
to strike, quiet to wait,
sleepless.
-- through metaphor to reconcile
the people and the stones.
Compose. (No ideas
but in things) Invent!
Saxifrage is my flower that splits
the rocks.
(--Poem by William Carlos Williams)
Particulars, he said. A poetry of particulars.
His familiar, repeated tag phrase 'no ideas but in things' means that statements grow from, and report back to, local particulars. 'The Poet and His Poems' (1939) strings together several slogans until it arrives at this:
It should
be a song - made of
particulars, wasps,
a gentian - something
immediate, open
scissors, a lady's
eyes - the particulars
of a song waking
upon a bed of sound.
Surprise, specificity, ordinariness, new aural shapes, a bit of household detritus: such a verse-manifesto portrays much of what Williams tried to do. It attempts, too, to show order emerging from a neglected realm - the emergence, not the final synthesis.
(--from London Review of Books, Vol. 24 No. 5,dated 7 March 2002 , "Chicory and Daisies," by Stephen Burt)
Let's be particular about one another.
Let's be particular about God.
Compose this way.
Each day.
A way.
Of life.