Sunday, August 06, 2023

going out, coming in

The mystery of spiritual journeying.

Ultreïa = further beyond

 ανάσταση = resurrection

The going out is the coming in.

Canadian author Sue Kenney – suekenney.ca – suggests that pilgrims on the way to Santiago would say “Ultreya” to which pilgrims on their way home would respond “Suseya”. For her the term would be intrinsically linked to the way back, which was at the time a very important part of the Camino de Santiago with no easy transportation means. https://www.ultreyatours.com/blog/the-meaning-of-ultreya-suseya-santiago-de-compostela/?cn-reloaded=1

Maybe that’s an invitational consequence of growing older — a meditation on destination-less travel (or is that desensitizing travail?)

So many I know delight in outward accomplishment, vacations to other continents, cycling or hiking glorious trails and mountains across the country. I salute them.

These days, I am accomplishing nothing, vacating the premises, doing kinhin in open-air terra-zendo, napping in imaginal reverie, chanting with birds and mewing cats.

Quite simply, there’s nowhere to go … I am … already dwelling.

Prosit!

four days of contemplation

 It is the sacred triduum of 

Hiroshima, Transfiguration and Nagasaki. 


America grew tired of God the Father

Preferring to rid itself of Jesus


Ushering in a new era of mass-killing

Crucifixion by nuclear destruction


Of course the acts were horrible

The mindless raving of exterior solution


We are left with interior silence and prayer

Seeing the cruelty, unrejecting Christ who


Lets be seen all IS and YES and HOLY

As we shade our sorrowing unseeing eyes 


This is the call of sacred numinous

Turn again and look, see what is there


See WHAT IS here

Entering emptiness


Released from delusional calculations

Warfare of comparison and dominance


Today, this transfiguration triduum,

Reject error of ignorant gain and greatness


See through love, see through wholeness

Right now, right here, may particular be seen


A new vision of each and any

This one, that one, anyone


Shining through many and all

Silent One Expression  — Inner Communion


Semblance of Christ

Within reflecting through 


A Heart Sutra inviting us

Beyond, awake, and wholly rejoicing

Saturday, August 05, 2023

if wishes were horses

 It doesn’t matter what I think about Donald J.Trump. But he should not be president again.

I don’t care whether he gets away with his crimes and unsupportable attacks on law enforcement, judges, prosecutors, citizenry, anyone who doesn’t kowtow to him, or someone who thinks for themselves and finds him repugnant.

I wish he’d go away.

I’d like our country to be decent, kind, thoughtful, and believable. He’s not.

If prayer has any purchase or validity, I pray he stops being so unbelievably disingenuous.

without nothingness, within emptiness —- (where/what god is)

 The nothingness

Without


Is not


The emptiness

Within


(Savor


This

Realization)

Friday, August 04, 2023

for a second the severed head does not realize

When brash thuggery

Mocks and derides and insults

Everyone suffers

Look at a dangerous man

Krishna as time sharpens sword

at end of friday evening conversation she said the words

Are you

Being

You


Yes


Are 

You Being,

You

been outside (so long)

 the dying are go-

ing within as God is with-

in -- make of it what 

you will -- no need to believe

we're outside now -- looking in

a hundred and two year old compañera

 We time together

she sleeping, bed, me in chair

listening, Richter,

as light descends out from room

I get up to go, say bye

Thursday, August 03, 2023

ένας (one) ... νας (you)

 One has

No inside

No outside


One

Is merely, wholly

One

are in we

Creating inside out. 

Where nothing ever was ... comes what is now ... becoming that which is.

 Something seen and felt — but still -- within, nothing there.

“Real?” You ask.

As real as real is, yes, of course, real. But don’t be fooled. Real is what mind is ... making through ... imagination. 

Nothing at core. Everything with care. A longing to cure.

Here’s Browning and Sayers:

 But here is the will of God, a flash of the will that can,

Existent behind all laws, that made them, and lo, they are! 

And I know not if, save in this, such gift be allowed to man, 

That out of three sounds he frame, not a fourth sound, but a star.

 

Consider it well: each tone of our scale in itself is nought, 

It is everywhere in the world-loud, soft, and all is said: 

Give it to me to use! I mix it with two in my thought: 

And there! Ye have heard and seen: consider and bow the head!' 

... Robert Browning: Abt Vogler.

"I mix it with two in my thought"; this is the statement of the fact of universal experience that the work of art has real existence apart from its translation into material form. Without the thought, though the material parts already exist, the form does not and cannot. The "creation" is not a product of the matter, and is not simply a rearrangement of the matter. The amount of matter in the universe is limited, and its possible rearrangements, though the sum of them would amount to astronomical figures, is also limited. But no such limitation of numbers applies to the creation of works of art. The poet is not obliged, as it were, to destroy the material of a Hamlet in order to create a Falstaff, as a carpenter must destroy a tree - form to create a table -form. The components of the material world are fixed; those of the world of imagination increase by a continuous and irreversible process, without any destruction or rearrangement of what went before. This represents the nearest approach we experience to "creation out of nothing", and we conceive of the act of absolute creation as being an act analogous to that of the creative artist. Thus Berdyaev is able to say: "God created the world by imagination."

This experience of the creative imagination in the common man or woman and in the artist is the only thing we have to go upon in entertaining and formulating the concept of creation. Outside our own experience of procreation and creation we can form no notion of how anything comes into being. The expressions "God the Father" and "God the Creator" are thus seen to belong to the same category — that is, of analogies based on human experience, and limited or extended by a similar mental process in either case.

(—from, The Mind of the Maker by Dorothy L. Sayers (Published 1941)

 I cannot imagine God. My mind would prefer to put something there. Some image. Some thought. Some narrative.

God has no place there. That’s ok, mind says, we’ll create a place called God. Churches, philosophies, theologies, and even secular savants, all create a place for God. Admission fees are charged. Rules promulgated. Sanctions applied. Apparel approved.

Rare is the inchoate imagination fixing no place to reside, no place to hide.

the great advantage of being alive 

                                                                     by e.e. cummings

the great advantage of being alive

(instead of undying)is not so much

that mind no more can disprove than prove

what heart may feel and soul may touch

— the great (my darling)happens to be

that love are in we, that love are in we

 

and here is a secret they never will share for 

whom create is less than have

or one times one than when times where —

that we are in love,that we are in love:

with us they’ve nothing times nothing to do

(for love are in we am in i are in you)

 

this world(as timorous itsters all

to call their cowardice quite agree)

shall never discover our touch and feel

–for love are in we are in love are in we;

for you are and i am and we are(above

and under all possible worlds)in love

 

a billion brains may coax undeath

from fancied fact and spaceful time–

no heart can leap,no soul can breathe

but by the sizeless truth of a dream

whose sleep is the sky and the earth and the sea.

For love are in you am in i are in we

          (poem, the great advantage of being alive,  by e.e. cummings)

Wednesday, August 02, 2023

hold life like a face

At Tuesday Evening Conversation someone asked about confession. 


It still seems to me that each person knows what is right what is wrong -- emotional distress or lack of loving upbringing not to the contrary.


If so, each person wishes to unburden themselves following promulgation of unseemly, unkind, or unhealthy behavior or thought intentions.


There's a grounded balance of equality of forces that resides within and around each individual. Quite likely, said ground also exists within and around each corporate institution however many officers or administrative personnel engage issues under consideration affecting multiple individuals or general public.


I think we know.


And we want to say what we know.


To be equitably, freely, and refreshingly, there where we are.


Poet Ellen Bass:

         The Thing Is

              BY ELLEN BASS


to love life, to love it even

when you have no stomach for it

and everything you’ve held dear

crumbles like burnt paper in your hands,

your throat filled with the silt of it.

When grief sits with you, its tropical heat

thickening the air, heavy as water

more fit for gills than lungs;

when grief weights you down like your own flesh

only more of it, an obesity of grief,

you think, How can a body withstand this?

Then you hold life like a face

between your palms, a plain face,

no charming smile, no violet eyes,

and you say, yes, I will take you

I will love you, again. 

Poem ©2002 Ellen Bass, "The Thing Is," from Poetry of Presence: An Anthology of Mindfulness Poems, (Grayson Books, 2017).

Is that the desired outcome following confession -- "to love you, again"? 

The eremitic impulse is to shy away from entangling proximity in favor of solitary attentiveness just off to the side. 

Even there, once a clearing of geographical collectivity has been made, there arises a sense of vacuity, an awareness of one without two, a stillness of ding-an-zich

In Kantian philosophy, the thing-in-itself (German: Ding an sich) is the status of objects as they are, independent of representation and observation. The concept of the thing-in-itself was introduced by the German philosopher Immanuel Kant, and over the following centuries was met with controversy among later philosophers.[1] It is closely related to Kant's concept of noumena or the object of inquiry, as opposed to phenomenon, its manifestations. (wikipedia)

Sometimes grief sits with you like reticent friend knowing that to remain wordless is to approximate (or to proximate) presence in a different metaphysic.

Everything, one assumes, is within everything else. What we experience as separateness is our reluctance to see what is there in ways that ordinarily cannot be seen. 

Some say that God is within. I think they want to say, but restrain themselves, that God is the within.

When I hermeneutically translated for my own prayerfulness the mantra -- here explicated by the Dalai Lama A Talk On Om Mani Padme Hum, "Om Mani Padme Hum" (Sanskrit pronunciation) or "Om Mani Peme Hung" (Tibetan pronunciation) -- I did it in idiorhythmic fashion.

For me it worded itself as: 

    Behold what is within without; Behold what is without within.

It is this translation (if you will) of the mantra that stays with me. It suggests for me non-duality, a "don't make two; don't make one" admonishment, an experience of wholeness that eludes definition, categorization, and division.

It is, at times, an experience that nears loneliness. But there is a concomitant realization that aloneness is not necessarily loneliness. 

Maybe Waylon Jennings and Willie Nelson came close in the chorus of their rendition of Mammas Don't Let Your Babies Grow up to Be Cowboys.

We greet one another in passing. No need to make anything more, nor less, than that. 


Perhaps we've missed the meaning of forgiveness, of sacrifice, of confession, of the teachings of the Buddha, of the revelation of the Christ. 


It's an inside job. The external world is perceptual gymnastic parallel bars against and around which we fling our bodies in twirling awkwardness round and round toward dismount and dismantlement.


The words try to tell us. They say:

Be still


and know


that/this --


I am


(--God)

Love, again. 

yes your honor, swear me in

 I'm moving back to

Washington DC, try to

get jury duty

today's headlines tomorrow's joke

 cartoon characters

laugh at their audience, take

their money and run

realizing the errors of my thinking

 Never buy a new computer the morning after a former president is (again) indicted for criminality.

He was.

I don’t.

The United States ponders folly with fierce foray into no-nonsense justice.

Tuesday, August 01, 2023

a fabric of silence so fine and old that even a breath could tear it

Maybe choice-less life is best. At least, a few-choices life. I still have sport jackets from early 1970s. They currently hang from line on sunporch taken from dark closet and waiting for sun to burn dampness, dust, and time from recesses of corduroy and wool.

A new wood-appearing vinyl flooring upset every inch of accumulation moving into boxes that lean against boxes against turned-over chairs and to-be-sorted-later piles of disturbed inessential but squatting residents of shelves and coffee table. They squint on bright porch. They know I'd just as soon leave them there and forage my way through their languid insouciance for the next five years.

Still, at 6:45am practice this morning, I pretend there's nothing else to do and sit zazen, chant heart sutra, pronounce four vows of the bodhisattva, mention names to be prayed for, then listen to one co-practitioner snort on round rug in middle of chapel/zendo and another co-practitioner pronounce a meta blessing for all relations all beings all for the greater glory of what is before us.

 It is important to remember that there is no “right” breath. If you carry with you the idea that your breath should be deep and full when in reality it is shallow, you immediately get into trouble. At times the breath is deep, at times shallow, at times freely flowing, and at other times it can feel blocked. Your practice is to be with your breath as it is, learning to let go of how you think things “should be.” Mindfulness of breathing is a practice of learning to harmonize your attention with what is, in this moment. Short, long, deep, shallow are all fine breaths. Trust your body; it knows what is needed.

 (--from, Receiving the Breath! A meditation Q&A with Christina Feldman, By Christina Feldman SUMMER 2003, tricycle)

It is August. July has slipped beneath the heat, torrential rains, perennial fog, and its overall dyspeptic thirty-one day stay around mid-coast Maine. I bid farewell, thank you for your efforts, see you next year (if either of us is yet continuing in the circling repetition of calendar reappearance.

In the unshelfing process, Adam Zagajewski's book of poems "Mysticism for Beginners" shows up and beckons:

On Swimming 

The rivers of this country are sweet
as a troubador’s song,
the heavy sun wanders westward
on yellow circus wagons.
Little village churches
hold a fabric of silence so fine
and old that even a breath
could tear it.
I love to swim in the sea, which keeps
talking to itself
in the monotone of a vagabond
who no longer recalls
exactly how long he’s been on the road.
Swimming is like prayer:
palms join and part,
join and part,
almost without end.
 
 

(Poem by Adam Zagajewski (1945-2021) from Mysticism for Beginners, Farrar Straus Giroux, 1997)

These breaths. There's one. There's one. And another. I'll be darned!

Darned, yes, the unfulfilled wish of dozens of socks in other hermit caverns in other rooms unfound and mostly forgotten.

Like my breath. A companionship that is always arriving always leaving sometimes staggering sometimes unbearably joyful, loved and let be.

Almost without end. 

Ainsi soit-il! 

Monday, July 31, 2023

the line which follows it

 At Sunday Evening Practice, mistakes and uncertainty. How do these inform practice of prayer and meditation?

We read about how Dogen spoke of One Continuous Mistake. Elsewhere, an article about What God, Quantum Mechanics and Consciousness Have in Common. Therein we wondered what might be the benefit of agnosticism?

Certainty eludes me. Not that I look for it. That search stopped a long time ago. 

I do not look for certainty.

I merely look.

I am convinced by very little, not much of anything, perhaps nothing.

What joy there is, and there is much, is the looking. Looking into. Looking at. Looking with. Looking as.

Whatever is seen is acknowledged. Appreciated. Attributed. Accessed, as best as possible.

I am a mendicant of affirmation -- I say yes to what appears. 

Skepticism does not obviate affirmation, it gives it shape and cautious approval. The yes is both wary and worrisome -- but it is also accommodating. 

The skepticism is not a judgment. It is a cautious consent to continue on.

Is it possible to say 'yes' to everything even when 'no' abides just out of sight waiting to see if it need appear when properly summoned?

In prison this morning, after talk of Tolstoy, Fitzgerald, Wiesel, Vonnegut and Herbert -- we touch on e.e.cummings who also quoted Blake:

Better worlds (I suggest) are born, not made; and their birthdays are the birthdays of individuals. Let us pray always for individuals; never for worlds. "He who would do good to another" cries the poet and painter William Blake "must do it in Minute Particulars"—and probably many of you are familiar with this greatly pitying line. But I'll wager that not three of you could quote me the line which follows it


     General Good is the plea of the scoundrel, hypocrite, &flatterer


for that deeply terrible line spells the doom of all unworlds; whatever their slogans and their strategies, whoever their heroes or their villains.

(--from, six non-lectures, by e.e.cummings) 

Ideas and ideologies, whether religious, philosophical, or political are the stuff skepticism walks around giving respectable distance.

Individuals, though, are a place to step closer to, to move more inquiringly near, and to invite into a shared turning of both words and dos y dos circumnavigation.

It is a dance.

Imagination steps into the room and asks 'why are you here?'

Sunday, July 30, 2023

look who shows up

 Two sneezes

Before bed

Sudden chill

Thây’s all

Surprisingly

the day I died while yet remaining still

 Who stands in a bathtub filled with water in desert mission

Who reaches over to move space heater closer to the tub

Who is thrown against wall saying “I’m still alive, I’m still alive”


This is how one becomes a zen Buddhist contemplative Catholic 

Alive, for now, I am, for now, still, for now

A member of the non-order of thomas merton and pseudo-death by


Electrical appliances and mortal electrocution watered against beatless heart  

Two years after Bangkok fabled shower story where Trappist monk lay dead after talk

Of Marxism and Monasticism in 1968 during the lie called Vietnam War


The saint of skeptical transcending vision 

smiling sardonic simplicity (dear annoying Tommy Merton)

zen masterful monk meandering this Sunday through breezy airwaves

Saturday, July 29, 2023

if you (don’t) think about it

 Nothing has happened before.

“Centuries of centuries and only in the present do things happen.”  (Jorge Luis Borges)

Nothing will happen after. 

keep room for those who have no place else to go

 In prison Friday morning considering non-transactional presence. 

Where each act is not about you not about me not about benefit or deprivation. Where there is a middle space, a space between, autonomous and auto-defining, repository of potential, possibility and  probable promise if left to its own, treated with care and concern, allowed to unfold and express its coming-to-be along with its retrieval-of-ancestral-worth.

Right there, not me not you, not one not two, the whole of it prior to dissection division distortion.

What is whole

This by Joy Harjo: 

For Calling The Spirit Back 
From Wandering The Earth 
In Its Human Feet

by Joy Harjo

Put down that bag of potato chips, that white bread, that 
bottle of pop.

Turn off that cellphone, computer, and remote control. 

Open the door, then close it behind you.

Take a breath offered by friendly winds. They travel
the earth gathering essences of plants to clean.

Give back with gratitude.

If you sing it will give your spirit lift to fly to the stars’ ears and 
back.

Acknowledge this earth who has cared for you since you were 
a dream planting itself precisely within your parents’ desire.

Let your moccasin feet take you to the encampment of the
guardians who have known you before time, 
who will be there after time.
They sit before the fire that has been there without time.

Let the earth stabilize your postcolonial insecure jitters.

Be respectful of the small insects, birds and animal people 
who accompany you.
Ask their forgiveness for the harm we humans have brought
down upon them.

Don’t worry.
The heart knows the way though there may be high-rises, 
interstates, checkpoints, armed soldiers, massacres, wars, and
those who will despise you because they despise themselves.

The journey might take you a few hours, a day, a year, a few
years, a hundred, a thousand or even more.

Watch your mind. Without training it might run away and
leave your heart for the immense human feast set by the 
thieves of time.

Do not hold regrets.

When you find your way to the circle, to the fire kept burning 
by the keepers of your soul, you will be welcomed.

You must clean yourself with cedar, sage, or other healing plant.

Cut the ties you have to failure and shame.

Let go the pain you are holding in your mind, your shoulders, your heart, all the way to your feet. Let go the pain of your ancestors to make way for those who are heading in our direction.

Ask for forgiveness.

Call upon the help of those who love you. These helpers take many forms: animal, element, bird, angel, saint, stone, or ancestor.

Call yourself back. You will find yourself caught in corners and creases of shame, judgment, and human abuse.

You must call in a way that your spirit will want to return. 
Speak to it as you would to a beloved child.

Welcome your spirit back from its wandering. It will return 
in pieces, in tatters. Gather them together. They will be 
happy to be found after being lost for so long.

Your spirit will need to sleep awhile after it is bathed and
given clean clothes.

Now you can have a party. Invite everyone you know who 
loves and supports you. Keep room for those who have no 
place else to go.

Make a giveaway, and remember, keep the speeches short.

Then, you must do this: help the next 

 person find their way through the dark.  

© Joy Harjo. Conflict Resolution From Holy Beings. W. W. Norton & Company, 2015.

Friday, July 28, 2023

on his right wrist

                (for L, as his drew nigh)

His watch was far from

What actual time it was

As if it mattered

Thursday, July 27, 2023

Wednesday, July 26, 2023

compañeras compañeros

 Community is teacher.

Practice is teacher.

Great doubt, skepticism, is teacher.

Finally, great faith, that which is beyond reason or belief, is true teacher.

I bow to my teacher/teachers

 Chris asked all attending at Tuesday evening conversation who our teachers are/have been.

Such a good question.

We mulled and pondered.

Now I ask you: Who are/have been your teachers?

Here’s a hint: they are alive within you within us.

Tuesday, July 25, 2023

simplemente no saber y un espacio vacío en el mundo*

 James the Greater, back then. They say he was the first of the apostles to be killed, it was 44AD. 

His memory is pilgrimage these days, Camino de Santiago.

Nineteen hundred years after his death, when circumstances brought my parents to the moment of birthing the possibilities inherent in a new life, I arrived, unknowing and an empty space in the world.

History hides so much. 

Beheading someone because they say what they've seen and heard was then, and is now, horrendous.

Where does one go when the mighty challenge the low?

Where does one go to sound the truth, to face the facts, to change one's life?

Look to one another.

See in one no-other.

No need to murder a different experience of reality.

Listen to it.

Just that.

Let what is being told be told -- without fear or the impulse to erase what is before you.

What has changed? 

Still, where I thought I was --

* just unknowing and an empty space in the world.

6:45am practice




When any one sits
Everyone is sitting

When any one practices
Everyone is practicing

Oh, my brothers and sisters
Welcome to chapel/zendo

Monday, July 24, 2023

when

 Why not now?

Sunday, July 23, 2023

mais oui

 At practice tonight E spoke of “the holiness of insignificance.”

A good phrase.

A sacred petit rien.

this is everything

 What is

Now

Is God

this changes everything

 What if

Now

Is God

Saturday, July 22, 2023

at the source, nothingness

 Today, Mary Magdalene.

Way to go, ma chérie!

Friday, July 21, 2023

stat virtus

 It is not pessimistic to say that half the population is bad.

It is not optimistic to say half the population is good.

Everything is halved. Yin and Yang. Angelic and devilish.

No one is all good. No one all evil.

It is all a balancing fulcrum, a middle point, comme ci comme ça.

That’s where we meet.

It’s where we begin. 

Nel mezzo del cammin di nostra vita

Thursday, July 20, 2023

sitting while chopin op.20 in b-minor is played on violin

 She has no recall

Memoryless with good smile

She does not eat meal

a comment on this morning’s post

  Comment on the fragment approaching nearness of poetry:

Is

     There

A 

     Poem

               Here

It occurs to me that the world of “there” is where we put “other.” It satisfies the penchant to distance and objectify, to “they” and “them.” It is a world of category and concept, of statistics and trends, of the foreign and stranger.

The world of “here” is that of no-other. Here evokes the close, the intimate, the non-differentiated. Here emerges presence. Here suggests embodiment, incarnated self-sameness, a divine realization of Itself. Here is where One dwells — (the mysteriously unfathomable, that which is beyond understanding, the nameless that we have called so many names.)

Poetry occurs, rarely and blessedly so, when something, some place, some intuition, some engagement — speaks or expresses itself (Itself) on its own without interference or contrivance or clever manipulation.

Hence, poetry is Being-written. Being-danced. Being-played. Being-sounded. 

Being-there-as-here. Being-here-as-there.

Cheslaw Milosz wrote in his poem Ars Poetica? —

The purpose of poetry is to remind us   
how difficult it is to remain just one person,   
for our house is open, there are no keys in the doors,   
and invisible guests come in and out at will.

If he is on target with this stanza, it might explain the reluctance to encounter or embrace poetry. (That, and poor pedagogy surrounding our early exposure to experiencing poetry in the academic classroom.)

Milosz gives us a good reminder of what is here. 

approaching nearness of poetry

1.

Is

     There

A 

     Poem

               Here


2.

Ταυ

      Crosses

                Distance 

Presencing

       What is

                 Revealing


3.

Itself

Wednesday, July 19, 2023

for hearing only -- ἀκροαματικός

Can't learn all words. Maybe some. Here's one: acroamatic  

Etymology

Borrowed from Latin acroamaticus, acroaticus (“esoteric”), at first chiefly in reference to the “esoteric” and originally oral teachings of Aristotle, from Ancient Greek ἀκροαματικός (akroamatikós, “for hearing only; esoteric”), from ἀκροάομαι (akroáomai, “to listen”).

Adjective

acroamatic (comparative more acroamatic, superlative most acroamatic)

    1. (rare, chiefly archaic) Of or pertaining to hearing. quotations ▼
    2. Esoteric, abstruse; (in particular) taught orally to select students and not disseminated. quotations ▼
    3. (education) Based on lectures or exposition by monologue. quotations ▼coordinate term ▼

Wiktionary 


The word appears in "On Distinguishing the Acroamatic from the Dogmatic", by Babette Babich, 2023, Journal for the Philosophical Study of Education.


To be a student, according to Nietzsche. is not as easy as many blithely identify themselves.

To be a student, Nietzsche argues in his lectures on the ‘future of our educational institutions,’ is to be a listener. To this same extent, Nietzsche (1980) emphasizes that attending university is about ‘hearing’ lectures: thus “all education toward culture is, as said, ‘acroamatic’” (p. 740).

At issue is Nietzsche’s emphasis on hearing, and above all on what it takes to be able to hear. Heidegger’s student, Gnther Anders, focuses on what he calls “listening” and the active role required of the listener (listening is not passive), and in the case of Nietzsche’s lecture series, this is complicated, since for Nietzsche, a Classicist, a Graecist, as at the time of his speaking everyone who had enjoyed a university education would and could be expected to understand Greek, as a facility with Greek (and of course Latin) was to be assumed, it was then a prerequisite for matriculating and thus for hearing university classes as well as for taking a degree. (Ibid xvi)

My early years, six decades ago, of studying Greek and Latin have not yielded a facility and proficiency, merely an appreciation and affection. My native language, English, has benefitted by the classical exposure of an Associate's Degree in Classical Languages, something which, at the time, seemed more a chore than a delight.

 The acroamatic, as Nietzsche emphasizes, is derived from the Greek ἀκροαματικός—“for hearing only”—and ἀκροάομαι—concerning listening—referring to ‘things heard,’ teachings communicated not in writing (think of Plato’s famous caution in the Phaedrus) but orally, just and only to and for those who have met the prerequisites for understanding and who are thus capable of hearing what is communicated. 

In the same way, Nietzsche’s provocative book subtitled ‘for all and none,” his Thus Spoke Zarathustra, emphasizes speaking, recounting the different “ways” Zarathustra “speaks” to his followers or disciples, to his animals, to the old saint he meets in the forest as recounted at the start of his Vorrede or Prologue, or to the crowd in the marketplace that hears him proclaim his conception of the “overhuman” and who, listening with their own convictions and expectations, take him not to be speaking of the human that is to be ‘overcome,’ whatever that might mean, but as the equivalent of an opening act for the tightrope entertainment they had all come to see. Esoteric as such, the ‘acroamatic’ method of instruction is traditionally contrasted with the erotematic, that is the dialogical method of teaching that is a matter of persuasion, i.e., belief and conviction, and dogma. The dialogical method has clear and convicted appeal; thus Nietzsche often invokes our ‘convictions’ as a word for our persuasions or prejudices, as these have faith on their side. The acroamatic is more challenging, relevant to the extent that one needs an account of a culture, of expert knowledge; thus Nietzsche’s reference to the epopts, and to the Platonic doctrine of the unwritten teaching, crucial to reflections on education, using the distinction between insiders and outsiders, esoteric and exoteric.8  (Ibid)

 Dialogical is a worthy method of entering into and moving through expressions of thought. Usually associated with communicating and learning, to dialogue has an implication of transparent interpenetration wherein one person lets go of the firm ground they imagine they occupy, and traverses through the interpositional-between, that fixed space or distance separating two beings, their opinions, their beliefs, their ruminations. This type of travel, one might even suppose, is a mystical or subatomic interchange of logos/mythos through the no-longer-defined-as-objects participants. 

  Old English dialogas (plural), from Latin from Greek dialogos, from dia ‘through’ + logos ‘word’; compare with Greek dialegesthai ‘converse with’; subsequently reinforced by Old French dialoge.    --cf online etymological dictionary 

The "through-ness" of our wording activity must be reconsidered. There is a neutrino-like behavior that experiences a no-barrier movement into and through whatever it encounters. Word is, if you will, a spiritual act in a world that seldom sees or experiences anything that does not fit the category of mass, material, or solidity. We have become estranged from the actual activity we engage in when we purport to converse, to dialogue, to speak the world into being with our articulation of what-is-real into reality.

The appreciation of reality is a gift of listening.

Authentic listening is not a ping-pong back and forth of lobbing language at an opponent during concept-combat, argumentation, or debate.

Listening is a spiritual practice of contemplative interpositional-betweenness wherein a new being, a third manifestation, arises in the open horizon diaphanously emerging as a numinous transcendence into a new way of thinking, feeling, and living in presence and manifesting wholeness.

Becoming a beholder.

The unforeseen occurrence of --

Beholding One Beholding.

Tuesday, July 18, 2023

if you are doing something, nothing is hidden

what will happen when 

formal practice disappears —

nothing will be seen

when box score listed at bottom shows free throws missed in n.i.t. championship

 new york times one jan

nineteen sixty one -- Buckeyes

beat Bonnies by two --

my former teammate, right guard 

missed five free throws, (sigh)

https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1961/01/01/98430353.html?pageNumber=127

opposent

                   (For RJK, d. 17july2019)

 not a misspelling

just a word for a once friend

there are no mistakes

tutti quanti, tutto il 

tempo — uncertain friendship